Thursday, December 17, 2009

Train Guide: Writing Legislation

With all of the analysis of the Senate healthcare reform bill, a lot of readers are writing in to ask how they could make that good of a bill themselves. Perhaps they want to make an equally great bill to give to a loved one for Christmas, or maybe they just want to see if they have what it takes to forge incredible legislation like the bill-smiths in our government. Luckily for you the Train has prepared a guide to crafting masterful legislation so that you can make a bill from the comfort of your own home! Just follow our easy step-by-step formula:

1. Choose a goal for your legislation. Is there a problem that urgently requires a solution? For the purposes of an example I'm going to use “reforming a hideously broken healthcare system” for the rest of this guide.

2. Take three or four of the most immediately obvious problems within this issue, and write commonsense solutions for them. Great job! Reform is on the way!

3. Invite people from the industry you're trying to reform to join in the process. Leave the room while they do whatever they want with your bill- I sure hope they don't add any loopholes to your reforms from step 2!

4. Now you need to lengthen the bill until it's too unwieldy for anyone to get a grip on. The proposal for the current Canadian health-care system was shorter than 50 pages- none of that for us! If you're having trouble breaking a thousand pages by using bizarre, dense language alone then you should consider taking passages from older, unrelated bills and using the “Find/Replace” function in your word processor to change the subject accordingly. With just a few clicks of your mouse the Smoot-Hawley Tariff is now the You-Someone Else Health-Care Reform Bill! Most of the sentences won't make sense anymore, but that's something we'll fix later.

5. Next, choose half a dozen people in your neighborhood who are opposed to your legislative goals, and give them free reign to edit the bill. You can refer to them as the Baucus Caucus, or the Lieberman Panel, or simply Those Douches. Step 5 isn't complete until they've all signed off on every aspect of your bill, so make sure you appease them in every way possible! You can rest assured that they'll be good faith negotiators, given their enmity to your goals and their unlimited power during this process.

6. Great job! You've made it pretty far. Now it's time for you to pick up a pen and add some more weak language vaguely addressing the issues you originally set out to fix. Perhaps you have a toned-down version of reform that might still have some place in the bill? Tentatively pencil it in, but make sure not to get your heart set on it- because now we…

7. Go back to the industry insiders and Those Douches! Run the entire thing past them again. And again. And again.

8. Print up a complete version of the bill as it stands, and take it to your local sewage processing plant. Dunk it repeatedly in the foulest substances you can find.

9. Take it to a sausage factory and run it through a meat grinder. Don’t bother sterilizing anything beforehand- in fact the more it resembles a scene from Midnight Meat Train, the better. Once you're done collecting the shredded bits of the bill and picking out the largest pieces of offal, run it through again for good luck.

10. Shoot it into space on a rocket made of radioactive waste. Guide the rocket into the Sun.

11. Use a solar panel to capture some of the energy coming back from the Sun after your rocket-bill explodes. Store the energy in a battery- we'll need it later!

12. Familiarize yourself with the principles of homeopathy as proposed by Samuel Hahnemann in the late 18th century. Specifically, we're going to utilize the “like cures like” theory to create a homeopathic bill. Choose something which creates the same symptoms as whatever problem you're trying to solve. Health-care reform is trying to fix an expensive, under-regulated system rife with corruption which has managed to compromise portions of our government… does this sound a little bit like the military industrial complex? I think so, so for my example I'm going to use the mission statements of several large military contractors as the base for my healthcare cure. After printing them out I take the pages and place them in a large vat of water and shake them vigorously- using machines powered by the battery with the energy from our initial bill!

13. Next we have to follow homeopathic principles by diluting our solution. Take a cup of the water out and set it aside. Empty your vat and fill it again with fresh water. Pour the cup you set aside back in, and shake the entire mixture again. Congratulations, you've just finished your first dilution! Homeopathy practitioners claim that the most effective treatments are diluted in this manner sixty times. Go ahead and do that- take a cup out, drain the rest, fill it back up, mix the cup back in and shake, drain again, etc, until you've diluted it sixty times.

14. Wikipedia points out that after sixty dilutions, “on average, this would require giving two billion doses per second to six billion people for 4 billion years to deliver a single molecule of the [material from the first dilution] to any patient.” Don't worry about that, though. Now it's time for you to pour your bill into the local water supply and deliver healthcare reform to all. You win!

I've been saving a surprise for the end of this guide: doing this would actually result in an even better bill than the one they're considering in the Senate right now. Why? Because your bill would do absolutely nothing, whereas the Senate bill is a train wreck that may end up deteriorating the state of American healthcare even further. Congratulations, you beat the Senate at their own game.

Which Side Are You On?

Are you in favor or real reform or a givaway to the health insurance companies? Are you with Joe Lieberman or Howard Dean?

Well at least Obama's making his position clear:
On Wednesday, White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs strongly hit back at former DNC Chairman Howard Dean for criticizing the Senate health care bill, suggesting, at one point, that Dean was being irrational and didn't understand the contents of the legislation.

"I don't know what piece of legislation he is reading," said Gibbs.

"I would ask Dr. Dean, how better do you address those who don't have insurance: passing a bill that will cover 30 million who don't currently have it or killing the bill?" he added. "I don't think any rational person would say killing the bill makes a whole lot of sense at this point."


Asked if Dean was acting irrationally, Gibbs replied: "I can't tell what his motives are, to be honest with you."
. . .
"If this is an insurance company's dream, I think the insurance companies have yet to get the memo," he summarized.
As Sam Stein points out, Gibbs must have missed Ben Smith's report where an insurance company lobbyist emailed him "we win", after the senate bill was negotiated. But regardless, calling Dean "irrational", and accusing him of not having read the bill? Where was one tenth of this anger towards any of the people actually responsible for giving us a shitty legislation?

And the president's feelings towards Joe Lieberman after he killed any prospect of a good bill?
Obama thanked Lieberman privately for his statement issued earlier Tuesday pledging support for the bill as long as the Medicare expansion and public option were eliminated from the bill, Lieberman said.
Well, fuck.

A reader at TPM says it best, it's not just about the losing:
I think people are pissed right now less at the fact that they didn't get what they wanted, and more at the fact that they feel like their people didn't really fight for it. Leaders don't always get what they want. But people recognize when true leaders at least give it a shot. And people judge that leadership by what they say in public and how hard they see them publicly pushing for it. Closed door negotiations don't count.

They wanted to see Obama push the public option and say that it was crucial, important part. His broad outlines of "cuts the deficit, improves coverage" is too bland and not something people can rally around, and he gives the impression that he's ceding power and leadership to a less capable bunch in the legislative branch.

They wanted to see news stories about how "staffers close to the majority leader" say that chaimanships and other perks were on the line for any Democrat who talked about filibustering this crucial bill.

They wanted to see congressional leadership and the president campaign hard for an "up or down vote on healthcare" the way the Republicans did so effectively for the judge appointments.

But none of that happened, and the things that people care about died with a whimper.

I know there's been a lot of game theory from people about how that would never work, etc. But the fact is that you can show leadership for big ideas and there's always still room to compromise at the end. At least then it would be clear that there was no other way, that you put up the good fight, better luck next time.

Instead they feel like the people they voted for and trusted to lead them failed. And it's hard to imagine making that same emotional commitment again in the future. Self defeating, yes. Temporary, maybe. But we're talking primal stuff here - people don't like wimps, not matter what party.
Watching Howard Dean completely dismantle Mary Landrieu on hardball last night is a nice reminder of what that type of emotional commitment and leadership actually looks like:


Any time someone tells you how you need to "come home" and support this bill, remember how much they've actually battled for real reform throughout this process. You don't owe them shit. They haven't fought for you, why should you fight for them?

Remove the mandate or kill the bill.

They've put us in a position where there are no good outcomes, but that doesn't mean we need to accept the worst possible one.

Train of Thought Lounge: The Replacements

I'm going to deliver a warning right now: some terrible stuff happened in the Senate today, and there are going to be some angry posts here on the Train over the next few days. For now, though, we're going to take a moment and acknowledge that it's a pretty cool time of the year- holidays are coming up, snow is on the forecast, etc. I missed all this stuff last year, and being here for the upcoming holidays... well, one could say I can't hardly wait.



"Can't Hardly Wait," from Pleased To Meet Me by The Replacements. Why does youtube only have this version, which replaces the horns with some synths? It is a mystery.

Now get ready for some posts celebrating the health reform bill, a disaster of epic proportions.

Tuesday, December 15, 2009

Suckers

Why do people treat the Democratic base like a bunch of suckers?

Frankly, because a lot of them are. Tremayne at Openleft has a nice recap of the health care debate:
Let's review the health care debate of 2009.

Democratic base: We demand X.

Sen. LieberNelsnowe: That's dead on arrival.

Democratic base: There's strong support for X.

Sen. LieberNelsnowe: I don't support it and there aren't enough votes anyway. Maybe I'll consider a Jiggered X.

Democratic base: We can't accept a Jiggered X. How about an opti-X?

Sen. LieberNelsnowe: We need to slow down and get this right. I think maybe I can support an opti-X.

Democratic base: Yay! We no longer demand X. Opti-X it is!

Sen. LieberNelsnowe: I cannot support Opti-X.

Democratic base: Wait, you said...

Sen. LieberNelsnowe: I said I'd think about it which I did. And I'm against it.

Democratic base: Jiggered X?

Sen. LieberNelsnowe: I'd strongly consider it.

Democratic base: (grumble) Fine, okay.

Sen. LieberNelsnowe: I cannot support Jiggered X. How about Expandicare?

Democratic base: (grrrr) Fine, that has some merit. We no longer demand X or opti-X or Jiggered opti-X. Instead, we demand Expandicare!

Sen. LieberNelsnowe: Sorry, I can't support Expandicare.

Democratic base: What! Why?

Sen. LieberNelsnowe: You accepted it, there must be something wrong with it. Besides, I never said I'd vote for it.

Democratic base: But you suggested it.

Sen. LieberNelsnowe: I suggest a lot of things. Like this: drop Expandicare and I'll strongly consider not filibustering.

Democratic base: Yay! Let's do it.

Sen. LieberNelsnowe: Suckers.
Reading the rec list at dailykos these days will drive you a bit insane. You get good diaries there to remind you that not everyone's lost the plot, but the good ones are often quickly rebutted with more popular diaries like "Listen to Obama and shut up" and "Joe Lieberman IS change we need".

Wish I could paint a nicer picture, but these are not good times.

Monday, December 14, 2009

Clodwatch for 12/14/2009

Today the award goes to Rep. Joe Barton (R-TX), who went a bit too far in his war on the environment and said something totally baffling:
CO2 is odorless, colorless, tasteless – it’s not a threat to human health in terms of being exposed to it. We create it as we talk back and forth.
Yes, the old test for poisonous gases: is it odorless? colorless? tasteless? Then it scientifically cannot be dangerous! Why, human beings create carbon monoxide, like he says. It couldn't possibly be dangerous, right?
Symptoms and signs of [excessive CO2 intake] include flushed skin, full pulse, extrasystoles, muscle twitches, hand flaps, reduced neural activity, and possibly a raised blood pressure... symptomatology progresses to disorientation, panic, hyperventilation, convulsions, unconsciousness, and eventually death.
But... but Barton said exposure doesn't pose a threat to human health! There goes my plan to sit in a small airtight space for a few hours and not die- my weekend is ruined. But that wasn't all Barton had to say:
So, and if you go beyond that, on a net basis, there’s ample evidence that warming generically — however it is caused — is a net benefit to mankind.
So global warming doesn't exist and isn't caused by CO2, which by the way isn't dangerous to people at all, but even if it does exist (regardless of the cause- either human activities or the natural warming of the earth or maybe magic) then it certainly isn't a bad thing and may in fact be good. Ladies and gentlemen, one of the leading Republican authorities on global warming: Joe Barton, clod extraordinaire.

It's Not Just Lieberman

Yes, Joe Lieberman may very well be one of the worst human beings on the planet. Even in a US Senate filled with narcissistic corporate whores who only care about the spotlight and enriching the industries that paid for their reelection, Lieberman his has risen to his own special level of asshattery.

But here's the thing: he's not president, he's not speaker of the house and he's not the majority leader. He's only as powerful as the Democratic leadership lets him be. Chris Bowers:
Nothing Lieberman is doing would be possible without the ongoing support of the majority of the Democratic caucus. If Democratic Senators wanted to punish Lieberman for his consistent transgressions against the party, they could. If Democrats wanted to use reconciliation, and just circumvent him altogether, they could do that to. But they are not going to do either.

As such, Lieberman is simply taking the power that is being handed to him by the rest of the caucus. Since he knows that Senate Democrats won't ever punish him, and won't ever circumvent him, he now has free reign to dictate whatever legislation he wants, get tons of face time with the White House and Senate leadership, regularly be the top story on news outlets around the country, receive millions in campaign contributions, and appease his Republican base (at this point, most of Lieberman's supporters are Republicans). It is a great deal for Lieberman, and it would not be possible without the ongoing consent of the majority of the Democratic Senate caucus.

Since we have already defeated Lieberman in a Democratic primary, there is nothing more severe we can do as progressive activists to directly threaten Lieberman. What we need to start doing is taking action against the Democrats who enable Lieberman and his ilk. If other Senate Democrats are not going to do anything about Lieberman taking control of the entire caucus, then really, what is the difference between those other Senators and Joe Lieberman?
Never thought I would echo George W. Bush, but we have reached the point where it is time to stop differentiating between problematic Senators like Joseph Lieberman and the other Senate Democrats who enable them.
Lieberman is many things, but stupid is not one of them. He (like many of us) knows that the majority of the Democrats in the senate a bunch of pussies when it comes to actually fighting for anything that matters. He knows that Harry Reid won't use the leverage he has to strip him of his chairmanship, or that Obama won't threaten him in the slightest. You'd think these people would be tired of getting repeatedly screwed over by this man, but apparently not.

When Lieberman was in the race for his political life in Connecticut against non-antichrist candidate Ned Lamont, Obama used his star power and popularity to endorse him in the primary. Lieberman repaid this favor by endorsing and campaigning for his opponent in the presidential election, which included standing on stage when vile, hateful slurs were used to attack him.

Other than this brief lapse with sanity, Obama returned to his usual bipartians/pragmatic/generic-David-Broder-cliche self upon winning the election, telling senate Democrats not to expel Lieberman from the caucus and to let him retain his chairmanship. And then we have yesterday, where Lieberman repaid him by obstructing Obama's main domestic initiative, vowing to join a filibuster to oppose it.

While most sane people see this finally crossing the uncrossable line, the White House seems to have decided to bend over and wait for his demands:
The White House is encouraging Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) to cut a deal with Sen. Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.), which would mean eliminating the proposed Medicare expansion in the health reform bill, according to an official close to the negotiations.

But Reid is described as so frustrated with Lieberman that he is not ready to sacrifice a key element of the health care bill, and first wants to see the Congressional Budget Office cost analysis of the Medicare buy-in. The analysis is expected early this week.

"There is a weariness and a lot of frustration that one person is holding up the will of 59 others," the official said. “There is still too much anger and confusion at one particular senator’s reversal.”
To call that a failure of leadership isn't strong enough. He may be a powerful Senator, but no one has done more to keep him in this position then Harry Reid and Barack Obama. They may not be scum of the earth like Lieberman is, but this situation is just as much their fault as it is his.

Bombing Towards Peace

A reply to Obama's Nobel Peace Prize acceptance speech from peace scholar David Cortright. Chris Hayes:
Cortright is the Director of Policy Studies at the Kroc Institute for International Peace Studies at the University of Notre Dame has been advocating peace since he was in the Army in Vietnam and organized his comrades against the war.
. . .
In the run-up to the Iraq war, Cortright helped lead Win Without War, conceived of as a"mainstream" alternative to ANSWER and other anti-war groups.
So Cortright's credentials as a pragmatic advocate of peace (whatever, in the final analysis, that means) are pretty impeccable: no starry-eyed, weak-kneed, incorrigible idealist, he! I emailed to ask him for his reaction, and he wrote back right away. "I found the Nobel speech disappointing." He continued: "To use the Nobel dais to justify the use of military force is unseemly. The president's characterization of the historic role of US military power was distorted, and his interpretation of just war theory was incomplete."
His full response follows:
The president asserted that US military policy has helped to "underwrite global security." More accurate would be an admission that many of our adventures have created global insecurity. Vietnam, the wars in Central America in the 1980s, the invasion of Iraq, countless interventions by the CIA--these and other actions have sown suffering and insecurity. The US has supported democracy in some settings but very often we have subverted democracy and overthrown legitimately elected democratic regimes, in Iran (1953), Guatemala (1954), Chile (1973), etc.

The president invoked just war principles but showed a shallow understanding of the criteria. The most important principle of just war theory is a presumption against the use of force, a belief that war is almost always unjust and can be justified only under the most dire circumstances and only if strict ethical criteria are satisfied. He mentioned a few of the criteria, without probing them in depth, but did mention the standard of ‘probability of success.' Under that criterion, the war in Afghanistan cannot be judged just, since there is very little probability that the war can be pursued to achieve military victory, however that is defined.

The president's assertions about Afghanistan did not acknowledge the fact that war is an inappropriate means of combating terrorism. The Rand Corporation study of 2008 on how terrorist groups end found that military force was responsible for ending terrorist groups in only 7 per cent of the cases. Political bargaining (43 per cent) and effective law enforcement (40 per cent) were the primary factors accounting for the end of terrorist groups. The military's own counterinsurgency doctrine calls for a campaign that is 80 per cent nonmilitary. The US effort in Afghanistan is the reverse, more than 80 per cent military.

Peace demands responsibility and sacrifice, yes, but it is built primarily through nonmilitary means. The president mentioned some of these, but he failed to mention that US foreign policy systematically undervalues these approaches. In Afghanistan the US is spending far more on military approaches than on development and humanitarian assistance.